声比拟理论在低马赫数流动气动噪声预测中应用广泛[1-2]。当固体边界静止且刚性时,频域声学积分方程为[3]:
| $ p'\left( {{x}} \right) = \int {{{T}_{ij}}\left( {{y}} \right)\frac{{{\partial ^2}G\left( {{{x}},{{y}}} \right)}}{{\partial {y_i}\partial {y_i}}}{\rm{d}}V} + {\rm{ }} \int {p\left( {{y}} \right)\frac{{\partial G\left( {{{x}},{{y}}} \right)}}{{\partial {{n}}}}{\rm{d}}S} $ | (1) |
其中,
| $\frac{{\partial G\left( {{{x}},{{y}}} \right)}}{{\partial {{n}}}} = 0$ | (2) |
那么方程(1)可简写为[4]:
| $p'\left( {{x}} \right) = \int {{{T}_{ij}}\left( {{y}} \right)\frac{{{\partial ^2}G\left( {{{x}},{{y}}} \right)}}{{\partial {y_i}\partial {y_i}}}{\rm{d}}V} $ | (3) |
这种满足声学边界条件的格林函数称为精确格林函数,是声波在空间传播的基本解,包含非紧致边界(边界的几何特征尺寸不是远小于声波波长)的声散射,从而有效简化气动声源的声学建模。通过理论解析可得到简单几何结构的精确格林函数,而对复杂非紧致边界,精确格林函数需采用数值方法获得[5-7]。
低马赫数流动噪声在半空间内的传播是气动声学领域的一个典型问题。若采用方程(3)进行噪声预测,就必须获得声波在半空间传播的基本解。当半空间边界为声学硬边界时,一般采用半空间格林函数[8]和边界元方法获取声传播基本解。在此基础上,利用Weyl-van der Pol公式[9-10]还可进一步得到阻抗半空间边界声散射的基本解,但这仅是一个工程近似处理方法。结合镜像源方法、等效源原理和边界元方法可得半空间阻抗边界声散射的基本解[11],但需要处理奇异积分。Ochmann[12]提出复等效源方法以避免奇异积分,并采用边界元方法计算了静止均匀介质中三维球体声散射的基本解[13]。需要指出的是,Ochmann并没有采用可靠算例验证复等效源方法的正确性。
本文基于等效源方法,建立半空间二维圆柱声散射基本解的理论模型,用以验证复等效源方法的可靠性,并采用边界积分方法获得低马赫数流动气动噪声在半空间传播的基本解,考虑了均匀运动介质对声传播的影响,为复杂物理问题的工程数值解提供理论支持。
1 复等效源方法与边界积分方程如图1(a)所示,半空间内
|
图 1 复等效源方法示意图 Fig.1 Schematic of complex equivalent source method |
| $\left( {{\nabla ^2} + {k^2}} \right){G_{h0}}\left( {{{x}},{{y}}} \right) = - \delta \left( {{{x}} - {{y}}} \right)$ | (4) |
其中,
| $\frac{{\partial {G_{h0}}({{x}},{{y}})}}{{\partial {{{n}}_b}}} + \gamma {G_{h0}}({{x}},{{y}}) = 0$ | (5) |
其中,
采用镜像源方法和复等效源原理考虑阻抗半空间边界的声散射问题,如图1(b)所示。镜像源和复等效源坐标分别为
| $ {G_{h0}}\left( {{{x}},{{y}}} \right) = {G_0}\left( {{{x}},{{y}}} \right) + {G_0}\left( {{{x}},{{y}}'} \right) + {\rm{ }} \int_0^{ + \infty } {a(s){G_0}\left( {{{x}},{{{y}}_s}} \right){\rm{d}}s} $ | (6) |
其中
利用
| $ \frac{\partial }{{\partial {x_2}}}\left[ {{G_0}\left( {{{x}},{{y}}} \right) + {G_0}\left( {{{x}},{{y}}'} \right)} \right] = 0 $ | (7) |
将式(6、7)代入式(5),得到:
| $\begin{split}& \gamma \left[ {2{G_0}\left( {{{x}},{{y}}} \right) + \int_0^{ + \infty } {a(s){G_0}\left( {{{x}},{{{y}}_s}} \right){\rm{d}}s} } \right] \\& +{\rm{ }} \int_0^{ + \infty } {a(s)\frac{\partial }{{\partial {x_2}}}{G_0}\left( {{{x}},{{{y}}_s}} \right){\rm{d}}s} = 0 \end{split}$ | (8) |
再利用关系式:
| $\frac{\partial }{{\partial {x_2}}}{G_0}\left( {{{x}},{{{y}}_s}} \right) = - {\rm{i}}\frac{\partial }{{\partial s}}{G_0}\left( {{{x}},{{{y}}_s}} \right)$ | (9) |
和分部积分,得:
| $\begin{split}& - {\left. {{\rm{i}}a\left( s \right){G_0}\left( {{{x}},{{{y}}_s}} \right)} \right|_{s = + \infty }} + {\rm{i}}a\left( 0 \right){G_0}\left( {{{x}},{{y}}} \right) \\& +{\rm{i}}\int_0^{ + \infty } {\frac{{\partial a\left( s \right)}}{{\partial s}}} {G_0}\left( {{{x}},{{{y}}_s}} \right){\rm{d}}s + 2\gamma {G_0}\left( {{{x}},{{y}}} \right) \\& +\gamma \int_0^{ + \infty } {a\left( s \right){G_0}\left( {{{x}},{{{y}}_s}} \right){\rm{d}}s} = 0 \end{split} $ | (10) |
如果
| $\left\{ \begin{array}{l} {\rm{i}}a\left( 0 \right) + 2\gamma = 0 \\ {\rm{i}}\dfrac{{\partial a\left( s \right)}}{{\partial s}} + \gamma a\left( s \right) = 0 \end{array} \right.$ | (11) |
解得:
| $a\left( s \right) = 2{\rm{i}}\gamma {{\rm{e}}^{{\rm{i}}\gamma s}}$ | (12) |
无论对质量型半空间边界
| ${\left. {a(s)} \right|_{s = + \infty }} = {\left. {2{\rm{i}}\gamma {{\rm{e}}^{{\rm{Re}}\left( \gamma \right){\rm{i}}s}}{{\rm{e}}^{{\rm{ - Im}}\left( \gamma \right)s}}} \right|_{s = + \infty }} \to 0$ |
即
| $ {G_{h0}}\left( {{{x}},{{y}}} \right) = {G_0}\left( {{{x}},{{y}}} \right) + {G_0}\left( {{{x}},{{y}}'} \right) + {\rm{ }}2{\rm{i}}\gamma \int_0^{ + \infty } {{{\rm{e}}^{{\rm{i}}\gamma s}}{G_0}\left( {{{x}},{{{y}}_s}} \right){\rm{d}}s} $ | (13) |
如果半空间中存在表面为S的刚性散射体,观察点
| $ {G_N}\left( {{{x}},{{y}}} \right) = {G_{h0}}\left( {{{x}},{{y}}} \right) + {\rm{ }}\int_S {{G_N}({{z}},{{y}})} \frac{{\partial {G_{h0}}({{x}},{{z}})}}{{\partial {{n}}({{z}})}}{\rm{d}}S $ | (14) |
式中,
对于二维问题,假设介质均匀,且沿
| ${G_0}\left( {{{x}},{{y}}} \right) = \frac{{\rm{i}}}{{4\beta }}{H_0}\left( {\bar k\bar r} \right){{\rm{e}}^{ - {\rm{i}}\bar kMa{\rm{ }}{r_1}}}$ | (15) |
式中,
| $ \; \beta = \sqrt {1 - M{a^2}} , \;\;\bar k = \frac{k}{\beta },\;\;{r_1} = \frac{{{x_1} - {y_1}}}{\beta }, \bar r = \sqrt {r_1^2 + {{\left( {{x_2} - {y_2}} \right)}^2}}{\text{。}} $ |
如图2所示,全空间中有两个半径为a的二维刚性圆柱C1和C2,圆心O1和分O2别位于x轴上下距离为h/2处,圆频率为
|
图 2 双圆柱声散射示意图 Fig.2 Schematic of sound scattering from two cylinders |
| ${G_h}\left( {{{x}},{{y}}} \right) = {G_0}\left( {{{x}},{{y}}} \right) + {G_S}\left( {{{x}},{{y}}} \right)$ | (16) |
其中
| ${G_0}({{x}},{{y}}) = \frac{{\rm{i}}}{{\rm{4}}}{H_0}\left( {kr} \right)$ | (17) |
其中
| ${g_{s1}}({{x}},{{y}}) = \frac{{\rm{i}}}{{\rm{4}}}\sum\limits_{m = - \infty }^{ + \infty } {{A_m}\left( {{x}} \right){{\rm{e}}^{ - {\rm{i}}m{\theta _{1y}}}}{H_m}\left( {k{r_{1y}}} \right)} $ | (18) |
| ${g_{s2}}({{x}},{{y}}) = \frac{{\rm{i}}}{{\rm{4}}}\sum\limits_{m = - \infty }^{ + \infty } {{B_m}\left( {{x}} \right){{\rm{e}}^{ - {\rm{i}}m{\theta _{2y}}}}{H_m}\left( {k{r_{2y}}} \right)} $ | (19) |
即
| $\frac{{\partial {G_h}({{x}},{{y}})}}{{\partial {{n}}}} = 0$ | (20) |
将源点置于圆柱C1表面,可得级数展开式:
| $ {G_0}({{x}},{{y}}) = \frac{{\rm{i}}}{{\rm{4}}}\sum\limits_{m = - \infty }^{ + \infty } {{{\rm{e}}^{{\rm{i}}m\left( {{\theta _{1x}} - {\theta _{1y}}} \right)}}{H_m}\left( {k{r_{1x}}} \right){J_m}\left( {k{r_{1y}}} \right)} $ | (21) |
式中,
| $ {{\rm{e}}^{ - {\rm{i}}m{\theta _{2y}}}}{H_m}\left( {k{r_{2y}}} \right) = \!\! {\rm{ }}\sum\limits_{n = - \infty }^{ + \infty } {{{\rm{i}}^{n - m}}{H_{m - n}}\left( {kh} \right){{\rm{e}}^{ - {\rm{i}}n{\theta _{1y}}}}{J_n}\left( {k{r_{1y}}} \right)} {\rm{, }}{r_{1y}} < h{\rm{ }} $ | (22) |
可得:
| $ {g_{s2}} = \frac{{\rm{i}}}{4}\sum\limits_{m = - \infty }^{ + \infty } {{{\rm{e}}^{ - {\rm{i}}m{\theta _{1y}}}}{J_m}\left( {k{r_{1y}}} \right) \cdot } {\rm{ }}\sum\limits_{n = - \infty }^{ + \infty } {{B_n}\left( {{x}} \right){{\rm{i}}^{m - n}}{H_{n - m}}\left( {kh} \right)} $ | (23) |
将式(18、21、23)代入边界条件(20)即可得到:
| $\begin{split}& {A_m}\left( {{x}} \right) - {\alpha _m}\sum\limits_{n = - \infty }^{ + \infty } {{B_n}\left( {{x}} \right){{\rm{i}}^{m - n}}{H_{n - m}}\left( {kh} \right)} = {\rm{ }} {\alpha _m}{{\rm{e}}^{{\rm{i}}m{\theta _{1x}}}}{H_m}\left( {k{r_{1x}}} \right) \end{split} $ | (24) |
其中,
将源点置于第二个圆柱 表面,可得:
| $\begin{split}& {B_m}\left( {{x}} \right) - {\alpha _m}\sum\limits_{n = - \infty }^{ + \infty } {{A_n}\left( {{x}} \right){{\rm{i}}^{n - m}}{H_{n - m}}\left( {2kh} \right)} = {\rm{ }} {\alpha _m}{{\rm{e}}^{{\rm{i}}m{\theta _{2x}}}}{H_m}\left( {k{r_{2x}}} \right) \end{split} $ | (25) |
将方程(24、25)改写为:
| $C_m^ \pm \left( {{x}} \right) - \sum\limits_{n = - \infty }^{ + \infty } {C_n^ \mp \left( {{x}} \right){M_{mn}}} = D_m^ \pm \left( {{x}} \right)$ | (26) |
式中,
| $\begin{split} C_m^ + \left( {{x}} \right) =& {A_m}\left( {{x}} \right),\\{\rm{ }}C_m^ - \left( {{x}} \right)=& \;{\left( { - 1} \right)^m}{B_{ - m}}\left( {{x}} \right), \\ D_m^ + \left( {{x}} \right) =& \;{\alpha _m}{{\rm{e}}^{{\rm{i}}m{\theta _{1x}}}}{H_m}\left( {k{r_{1x}}} \right),{\rm{ }} \\ D_m^ - \left( {{x}} \right) =& \;{\alpha _m}{{\rm{e}}^{ - {\rm{i}}m{\theta _{2x}}}}{H_m}\left( {k{r_{2x}}} \right), \\ {M_{mn}} =& \;{\alpha _m}{{\rm{i}}^{n - m}}{H_{n + m}}\left( {kh} \right) \\ \end{split} $ |
解线性方 程组(26)即可得到
| ${g_{s1}}({{x}},{{y}}) = \frac{{\rm{i}}}{4}\sum\limits_{m = - \infty }^{ + \infty } {C_m^ + ( {{x}} ){{\rm{e}}^{ - {\rm{i}}m{\theta _{1y}}}}{H_m}( {k{r_{1y}}} )} $ | (27) |
| ${g_{s2}}({{x}},{{y}}) = \frac{{\rm{i}}}{{\rm{4}}}\sum\limits_{m = - \infty }^{ + \infty } {C_m^ - ( {{x}} ){{\rm{e}}^{{\rm{i}}m{\theta _{2y}}}}{H_m}( {k{r_{2y}}} )} $ | (28) |
采用等效源方法将图3(a)所示的半空间圆柱声散射转化为图3(b)所示的全空间双圆柱声散射。对质量型阻抗半空间边界,镜像源和等效源坐标分别为
|
图 3 等效源方法示意图 Fig.3 Schematic of equivalent source method |
| $ {G_A}\left( {{{x}},{{y}}} \right) = {G_h}\left( {{{x}},{{y}}} \right) + {G_h}\left( {{{x}},{{y}}'} \right) + {\rm{ }}2\gamma \int_0^{ + \infty } {{{\rm{e}}^{\gamma s}}{G_h}\left( {{{x}},{{{y}}_s}} \right){\rm{d}}s} $ | (29) |
同理,对刚度型阻抗半空间边界,有:
| $ {G_A}\left( {{{x}},{{y}}} \right) = {G_h}\left( {{{x}},{{y}}} \right) + {G_h}\left( {{{x}},{{y}}'} \right) {\rm{ }} - 2\gamma \int_0^{ + \infty } {{{\rm{e}}^{ - \gamma s}}{G_h}\left( {{{x}},{{{y}}_s}} \right){\rm{d}}s} $ | (30) |
其中等效源坐标为
如图4所示,半径
|
图 4 半空间圆柱声散射算例示意图 Fig.4 Schematic of the computational cases for sound scattering from a cylinder in half-space |
取
|
图 5 质量型平面上方刚性圆柱声散射在P点随波数的变化 Fig.5 Wave number dependence of sound scattering from a cylinder above a mass-like impedance plane at point P |
波数为20时,点源辐射声波的波长与圆柱直径的比值约为3,圆柱声学非紧致,声散射的空间指向性分布如图6所示。理论解与数值解在所有的观察点处相吻合。对刚度型半空间边界,取阻抗参数
|
图 6 质量型阻抗平面上方圆柱声散射指向性分布图 Fig.6 Acoustic directivities of sound scattering from a cylinder above a mass-like impedance plane |
对直径为
取P点为观察点,假设介质静止均匀。不考虑圆柱边界和半空间边界对声传播的影响,认为声波在全空间中自由传播,格林函数虚部
|
图 7 自由空间 |
|
图 8 全空间 |
从方程(3)可知,若气动声源
|
图 9 全空间 |
对图4所示半空间圆柱,由于圆柱距离半空间边界足够远,可忽略半空间边界对流动的影响,认为无量纲涡脱落频率仍为
|
图 10 半空间 |
图11为半空间边界分别为声学硬边界、质量型和刚度型阻抗边界时,精确格林函数
|
图 11 半空间 |
考虑介质运动对声传播的影响,取无穷远来流的速度为均匀介质的运动速度,即介质运动马赫数为
|
图 12 介质运动 |
图13是半空间边界为声学硬边界且介质均匀运动马赫数为0.25和0.3时精确格林函数虚部空间二阶混合偏导数
|
图 13 介质运动 |
基于复等效源方法,建立了半空间中非紧致声传播基本解的边界积分方程,考虑了介质均匀运动对声传播的影响。同时,利用等效源方法提出了一种半空间二维非紧致圆柱声散射模型,推导了静止介质中声散射基本解的理论表达式,验证了边界积分方程基本解的正确性。
对直径0.1 m、无量纲涡脱落频率
尽管本文研究的是二维声传播问题,但复等效源方法对三维声散射问题也是有效的。在后续工作中,我们将利用边界积分方程的基本解对复杂结构的气动噪声进行预测。
| [1] |
基于 LES 方法的增升装置气动噪声特性分析[J]. 空气动力学学报, 2016, 34(4): 448-455. LU Q H, CHEN B. Analysis of aeroacoustics characteristics of high lift device using LES method[J]. Acta Aerodynamica Sinic, 2016, 34(4): 448-455. DOI:10.7638/kqdlxxb-2014.0140 (in Chinese) |
| [2] |
方腔流动气动噪声边界散射数值预测方法研究[J]. 空气动力学学报, 2015, 33(5): 617-623. WANG F, LIU Q H, CAI J S. Numerical prediction method of aerodynamic noise including boundary scattering generated by high subsonic cavity flow[J]. Acta Aerodynamica Sinica, 2015, 33(5): 617-623. DOI:10.7638/kqdlxxb-2015.0004 (in Chinese) |
| [3] |
毛义军. 低马赫数流动中声比拟理论的拓展及其应用研究[D]. 西安: 西安交通大学, 2010. MAO Y J. Development of acoustic analogy for low Mach numbers flow and its applications[D]. Xi’an: Xi’an Jiaotong University, 2010(in Chinese). |
| [4] |
GLOERFELT X, PÉROT F, BAILLY C, et al. Flow-induced cylinder noise formulated as a diffraction problem for low Mach numbers[J]. Journal of Sound and Vibration, 2005, 287(1-2): 129-151. DOI:10.1016/j.jsv.2004.10.047 |
| [5] |
TAKAISHI T, MIYAZAWA M, KATO C. A computational method of evaluating noncompact sound based on vortex sound theory[J]. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 2007, 121(3): 1353-1361. DOI:10.1121/1.2431345 |
| [6] |
HU F, GUO Y, JONES A. On the computation and application of exact Green ’s function in acoustic analogy[C]//11th AIAA/CEAS Aeroacoustics Conference, Monterey, California. Reston, Virigina: AIAA, 2005. doi: 10.2514/6.2005-2986.
|
| [7] |
BONAMY C, JORDAN P, GERVAIS Y. Tailored near-field Green ’s functions for arbitrary geometries[J]. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 2010, 128(5): 2581-2588. DOI:10.1121/1.3365240 |
| [8] |
WILLIAMS J E F, HALL L H. Aerodynamic sound generation by turbulent flow in the vicinity of a scattering half plane[J]. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 1970, 40(4): 657. DOI:10.1017/s0022112070000368 |
| [9] |
MILLER S A E. The prediction of jet noise ground effects using an acoustic analogy and a tailored Green's function[J]. Journal of Sound and Vibration, 2014, 333(4): 1193-1207. DOI:10.1016/j.jsv.2013.10.028 |
| [10] |
LUI W K, LI K M. The scattering of sound by a long cylinder above an impedance boundary[J]. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 2010, 127(2): 664-674. DOI:10.1121/1.3273891 |
| [11] |
OCHMANN M. Source simulation technique for acoustic radiation problems[J]. Acustica, 1995, 81(6): 512-527. |
| [12] |
OCHMANN M. The complex equivalent source method for sound propagation over an impedance plane[J]. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 2004, 116(6): 3304-3311. DOI:10.1121/1.1819504 |
| [13] |
OCHMANN M. A half-space BEM for the simulation of sound propagation above an impedance plane[C]//Proceedings - European Conference on Noise Control, 2008: 2917-2922.
|
| [14] |
ADAM M. Application of translational addition theorems to electric and magnetic field analysis for systems of circular cylinder[D]. Winnipeg: The University of Manitoba, 2012.
|
| [15] |
ORSELLI R, MENEGHINI J, SALTARA F. Two and three-dimensional simulation of sound generated by flow around a circular cylinder[C]//15th AIAA/CEAS Aeroacoustics Conference (30th AIAA Aeroacoustics Conference), Miami, Florida. Reston, Virigina: AIAA, 2009.
|
2021, Vol. 39


